The Bagel Fair Story

We’re very excited to announce that Bagel Fair now takes credit and debit cards!

Bagel Fair Incorporated, established in 1975, is a 2nd generation family owned business located in Nora Plaza Shopping Center (across from Target). Bagels are made fresh daily, from a family recipe over 100 years old. Come in and experience Indy’s only real New York bagels.

The Bagel Man

Our Bagels:

    • Plain
    • Sesame
    • Poppy
    • Bialy Bagel
    • Cinnamon Raisin
    • Onion
    • Combination
    • Garlic
    • Salt
    • Pumpernickel
    • Jalapeño
    • Apple Cinnamon
    • Blueberry
    • Multigrain
    • Bialy

A bialy is a baked (not boiled), flat bagel topped with onions, poppy seeds, and salt. Since they aren’t boiled, they have a chewier texture. Come in as early as 8:30 on a Sunday, and get them while they last- they sell out quickly!

Cream cheese spreads:

  • Plain
  • Lox
  • Strawberry
  • Scallion
  • Veggie
  • Lite (Low Fat)


  • Egg
  • Cheese (Pepper jack, Provolone, American, Swiss, Cheddar)
  • Salami
  • Corned Beef
  • Pastrami
  • Turkey
  • Peanut Butter
  • Strawberry Jam
  • Cinnamon and Sugar
  • …and more!

Bagel Sandwiches, Coffee, Fountain Drinks, Milk, and Juice